Skip to Content, Navigation, or Footer.
Support independent student journalism. Support independent student journalism. Support independent student journalism.
The Dartmouth
March 17, 2026
The Dartmouth

Maggie Talks To Strangers

True or false: Hipsters are into everything that's "cool" or "edgy."

Answer: False. Hipsters were over anything cool or edgy long before you even knew it existed.

True or false: Hipsters judge me because of my love of ice hockey and sense of "Minnesota nice."

Answer: True. I've tried to fix this before. Every single time I go to New York City. I go to Don Hills, I wear bandanas around my neck. It never works. Inevitably, I forget that I'm not in the Midwest anymore and offer to "whip up dinner," or jump-start someone's car.

Not this time, Dartmouth. I'm going to New York City next weekend and this time I've got to be hip enough. Thus, I assembled a panel of experts: Sean Adams '07, Don Stewart '06 and John James '08. Sean, Don and John gave me a tutorial as they set up for band practice. I'd make a plug for Sean, Don and John's band, but then they'd be "over it" by the time this article hits the stands. So, here's what they've got to say:

Don: We can start by saying that it's not hip to be interviewed in "The Mirror." We didn't want to be interviewed.

So how do I become a hipster?

Don: Well, first you're going to have to cut your hair. Something, I don't know, kind of long. Maybe tone it down a little bit. More conservative, you know? Also, do you know what topsiders are?

Like, the shoes?

Don: Yeah, your sandals are way too casual.

What do you think, Sean?

Sean: You should straighten your hair. I think you have to be prepared to, uh, I don't know. What do you have to be prepared to do?

Get Parkhursted?

Sean: No. That comes with the territory.

What hip music should I listen to? What books should I read?

Don: I think you either have to have the best taste or the worst taste. I think that's what it comes down to.

Sean: I mean, when it comes to TV, I pretty much only watch dating shows on MTV.

Don: You listen to a lot of pop music.

Sean: Listen to a lot of pop music. Lots of N'Sync.

Don: Basically, everything you thought was cool when you were a teenager was completely wrong. And everything you thought was really un-cool about you being a pre-teenager is really f*cking sweet.

John: That's true.

Don: The added benefits are that now you can drink and do drugs.

John: Which we don't do.

Sean: I think I just got grease from my drums on me.

Don: So what do you see in yourself that needs improvement?

Well, I only realized that I needed to become hip a couple hours ago. I need to do it because I'm going to New York City next weekend.

Don: Oh, sh*t. New York.

So does it help to be in a band?

Don: I mean, I think it reins you in a little bit. The level of grounding and insecurity that makes you want to be in a band also keeps you from walking around in platform boots wearing only unitards like, "club hipster" stuff.

Sean: I mean, being that kind of hipster takes a lot of time. Too much thought.

What else?

Don: Well, either have a ton of money or no money at all.

Sean: Good point. Also, you should probably figure out something that's been socially unacceptable for a long time. Like, an addiction is always a good one. Find yourself some sort of addiction.