Skip to Content, Navigation, or Footer.
Support independent student journalism. Support independent student journalism. Support independent student journalism.
The Dartmouth
December 14, 2025 | Latest Issue
The Dartmouth

Toe to Toe: Hodes versus Schmidley (Schmidley)

Shaquille O'Neal is now a Sun,

and Pao Gasol is now a Laker. As

we all know, this year's Western

Conference Playoffs are merely

an audition to square off against

a (presumably healthy) Celtics

team in the NBA Finals. The odds

makers, many pundits, and most

importantly, Alex Hodes, all favor

the Lakers to rise to the occasion.

I'm gonna go with the Suns -- I

really do believe that Shaq is the

answer for an ultra-talented and

experienced, yet still title-less

Suns team.

At first glance, the Lakers are

the more alluring choice--a fact

that could explain why the many in

the sports community views them

as best in the West right now. With

the addition of Gasol -- an athletic,

high-percentage player and

one of the league's more feared

presences in the front court, the

Lakers are fully equipped to make

a title run.

The remainder of the Suns new

and improved nucleus is a formidable

unit, including a budding

Andrew Byum, veteran Lamar

Odom, the much respected sage

Derek Fisher, and lastly, a man

who needs no adjective to describe

him--

Kobe.

Gasol's stat line through six

games (he's been averaging 20

points and eight rebounds per game

while knocking down shots at an

impressive .645 clip) gives Lakers

enthusiasts plenty of reason to be

optimistic.

It's certainly safe to say, after

watching how seamlessly he's

been integrated, both technically

and chemistry-wise, that opposing

teams are going to have their

hands full with Phil Jackson's new

toy set.

Though we've yet to see Shaq

on the court with his new team,

there's one safe assumption we can

still make about his transition to the

Suns--that it will provide him with an

inestimably better environment --

both individually and team-wise--to

succeed. The Heat are currently in

the throws of a rebuilding stage.

Shaq is a storied player -- a precious

gem in NBA lore.

Simply put, at this stage in his

career, he doesn't deserve to be

shackled in his quest for another

NBA title. He does already have

four, of course, but a player of Shaq's

caliber deserves as many shots as

he wants.

His chances look good, too.

He's got the best pure point

guard of his generation to run the

offense, and a remainder of a supporting

cast that, despite losing

Amare Stoudamire, is still loaded

with weapons. Most fully expect

Shaq's modest stat line (14 points

and seven rebounds per game)

to improve, and I would tend to

agree.

The most important thing Shaq

brings to the Suns, however, is

experience and veteran leadership.

The savvy he's gained throughout

his career, which has included six finals

appearances, looks like it could

be the missing piece in the Suns

clubhouse. This savvy, combined

with the inevitable improvement

in Shaq's game that will ensue after

he gets a few games under his belt,

should catapult the Suns into the

finals.

If I haven't convinced you yet,

consider what Steve Nash had to say

upon hearing Shaq would be joining

the Suns: "There's doubts and a risk

to everything. I know that's going to

be a favorite talking point for all the

media, but for us the talking point

is we've got an incredible, huge,

talented, charismatic player in our

locker room now...This sounds like

it's going to be a lot of fun."

That's quite a ringing endorsement.

To this writer, it smacks of

"title appearance". Then again, I was

the one who immortalized the Pats

before the Super Bowl, so what do

I know about sports? See you next

week.

just under 20-10 in points and rebounds,

which will prove critical in taking some

pressure off Kobe. More importantly,

Gasol represents a second big body

along with Bynum, causing impossible

mismatches around the league.

The Lakers have no discernible flaws,

which bodes well for their championship

prospects.

Phoenix is banking on Shaq's experience

in the postseason and all-around

locker room karma to keep them

playing deep into June. But it's going

to be the on-court production of Gasol,

coupled with the ferocity of Kobe, that

will have the Lakers revising their summer

plans. And for those who think

Gasol lacks the experience to keep

up his level of play in the postseason,

remember, he was the leader of Spain's

World Championship-winning team.

More importantly, if both teams

fail to achieve glory this season, the

Lakers have set themselves up much,

much better for the foreseeable future.

The Suns are aging. Shaq isn't getting

any healthier, or less expensive. The

Lakers, on the other hand, with Gasol,

Kobe and Odom in their primes, not to

mention a rapidly improving Bynum,

have a core that could very well contend

for years to come. No matter what

Schmidley argues, the facts speak for

themselves: Gasol makes the Lakers

more dangerous title contenders than

the Suns. Sorry, Shaq.

Associaed Press

Pau Gasol is averaging nearly 20 points and 10 rebounds per game.

Associaed Press

Shaquille O'Neal has four NBA championships under his belt and is looking to win a fifth ring in Phoenix.

Trending