Skip to Content, Navigation, or Footer.
Support independent student journalism. Support independent student journalism. Support independent student journalism.
The Dartmouth
April 24, 2024 | Latest Issue
The Dartmouth

Toe to Toe: Hodes versus Schmidley (Hodes)

A recent rash of trades is likely to

produce the familiar: By the end of

the season, there is a good chance

that either Kobe Bryant or Shaquille

O'Neal will hoist the Larry O'Brien

Trophy. The Lakers and Suns, locked

in a fierce Pacific Division duel, have

clearly vaulted themselves to the top

of the pack in the Western Conference

with their respective acquisitions of

Pau Gasol and Shaq. Yet while the

Suns traded away a valuable asset in

Shawn Marion, what some may argue

was addition by subtraction, the Lakers

fleeced the Grizzlies by adding Gasol

in the biggest steal since the Louisiana

Purchase.

Make no mistake, I firmly believe

that both teams have put themselves

in a better position to win the NBA

championship. The Suns weren't going

anywhere with the incompatible, and

possibly combustible, combination of

Marion and Amare Stoudemire. Now,

with a core of Steve Nash, Amare, and

Shaq, not to mention a stellar supporting

cast, the Suns will still compete with

the rest of the best. The big difference,

however, is that the Suns can now

count on a much stronger clubhouse

chemistry, which should never be

underestimated.

Yet while some may question whether Shaq for Marion represents

a true improvement, no one will doubt

that the Lakers went from Bruce Banner

to Hulk when they upgraded from

Kwame Brown to Gasol--let's just

hope they don't tank as badly as the

film. Andrew Bynum, Gasol, Lamar

Odom, Kobe, and Derek Fisher form

one of the most well-rounded starting

fives in the league. And no, it doesn't

hurt to have the league's best player,

either.

The Suns did not acquire the same

Shaq who won three titles on the Lakers.

They didn't even get the Shaq

who rode Dwyane Wade's coattails

to a fourth with Miami. Rather, they

got a Big Aristotle who is increasingly

resembling the real Aristotle--ancient.

For starters, he's nowhere near fullstrength,

and there's no guarantee that

he'll ever be effectively healthy again.

Superman found his Kryptonite, and

the 325-pound behemoth from LSU will

be 36 come March. While his career

averages are beyond excellent, they're

way down this year. In fact, he's averaging

fewer points and rebounds than

Gasol, all the while recording more

fouls and continuing to be an ineffective

presence down the stretch. His

inability to hit from the charity stripe

has reached new lows, dipping below

50 percent this season.

With Gasol, the Lakers will face no

such problems. The Spaniard averages just under 20-10 in points and rebounds,

which will prove critical in taking some

pressure off Kobe. More importantly,

Gasol represents a second big body

along with Bynum, causing impossible

mismatches around the league.

The Lakers have no discernible flaws,

which bodes well for their championship

prospects.

Phoenix is banking on Shaq's experience

in the postseason and all-around

locker room karma to keep them

playing deep into June. But it's going

to be the on-court production of Gasol,

coupled with the ferocity of Kobe, that

will have the Lakers revising their summer

plans. And for those who think

Gasol lacks the experience to keep

up his level of play in the postseason,

remember, he was the leader of Spain's

World Championship-winning team.

More importantly, if both teams

fail to achieve glory this season, the

Lakers have set themselves up much,

much better for the foreseeable future.

The Suns are aging. Shaq isn't getting

any healthier, or less expensive. The

Lakers, on the other hand, with Gasol,

Kobe and Odom in their primes, not to

mention a rapidly improving Bynum,

have a core that could very well contend

for years to come. No matter what

Schmidley argues, the facts speak for

themselves: Gasol makes the Lakers

more dangerous title contenders than

the Suns. Sorry, Shaq.